The Great American Rip-Offs

For a hell of a long time, I've noticed one recurring trend with American films, books, and series. They're based heavily on a Japanese original.

I'm not calling the American entertainment (for most part) industry as copy cats...wait, yes I am. Seriously, since time immemorial, anything Japanese that's cool and hip (some controversial) has an American "counter-part."

The sad thing about it is the world pays more attention to the copied, less cool version of that certain production (Oh power of Hollywood) and assumes that it's the Japanese who leeched off the idea that the brilliant Americans thought of themselves. Sigh.

Obviously, not all Jap products are copied (it would be too obvious if they were), but still. They're COPIED.

Can't find any movies or books that Americans redid? Then, let me have the pleasure of pointing them out to you.


TEAM JAPAN: Battle Royale vs TEAM AMERICA: The Hunger Games

THE COMMON THEME:
Kill or be killed

THE ORIGINAL: BATTLE ROYALE (2000)
 In Koushun Takami's controversial epic, Japan's youth wages a rebellion against the adults; cutting classes, committing crimes and the like. Threatened, the grown ups decide to pass the Millennium Educational Reform, or Battle Royale Act. The reform basically dictates that a random junior high class will be chosen and kidnapped to be placed in a deserted island. Here, the students are forced to kill each other in front of the whole nation until only one student survives within three days. If they refuse or if more than one still stands after the designated time, bombs attached to their necks go off.

THE COPY: THE HUNGER GAMES (2008)
The story takes place in the ruins of North America, then currently known as Panem. The nation consists of twelve districts and one ruling and cruel government residing in the Capitol, basically another district, but much nicer and better-looking than the others. Being the evil dictators that they are, the Capitol forces each of the twelve districts to send two tributes, one boy and one girl, to fight in the Hunger Games, a "fight to the death on live TV." Why? Well, for the sake of entertainment of course. 

TEAM JAPAN: Ringu vs TEAM AMERICA: The Ring

THE COMMON THEME:
Watch the cursed video and die in seven days

THE ORIGINAL: RINGU (1998)
A group of teenagers vacationing in a resort find an unlabeled video in their cabin. Curious, they decide to watch it. The video was weird, showing random flashes of a woman combing her hair, the word 'eruption' and a still shot of a well. Thinking nothing of it, they go home only to die at the exact same time after a week. Reiko, a reporter, hears about the death of her niece, one of the teenagers, and decides to investigate, which leads her to watching the video herself. Convinced that she only has a week to live, she contacts her ex husband to help her break the so-called curse. With only hours left before her death, Reiko miraculously manages to stop the chain of deaths caused by Sadako, a disturbed girl who died in a well and concocted the video. However, having watched the copy of the video, her ex hubby dies at the hand of Sadako herself after she climbs out of the TV.

THE COPY: THE RING (2002)
America's version focuses on Rachel and her investigation into the mysterious death of her niece. Through a bit of legwork, she discovers that Katie had snuck away with her friends to a cabin a week before her death and had watched a video with her friends. 7 days later, all four of them were dead at the exact same time they watched the video. This leads her to the same cabin where the kids watched the video. She watches the tape herself, bearing witness to a disturbing chain of black-and-white imagery. Shortly afterwards, like the teens before her, she receives a whispered phone call telling her she will die in 7 days. As the film continues both her friend Noah  and her son Aidan also see the film and fall under the same curse. 
[taken from http://www.best-horror-movies.com/the-ring.html. no infringement intended]

These are just two of the many other productions that America has copied. Seeing as I have a slow Net at the moment, I can't really post and compare them all. However to give you an idea of what the others are, I'll spell some of them out for you.


Word of advise to American film makers, stick to action films. Here, your fancy special effects can work and can be your saving grace in case the plot's bad. Trust me, the horror flicks you copy off of Japanese maestros would still pretty much suck even if your effects are better than theirs.

2 comments:

littleblackdress said...

Argh. I hate the American counterparts of Battle Royale and One Missed call. Did no justice to the originals at all.
And they still make terrible sequels for 'em.

Derek said...

There are a lot of books out there with similar premises. I think that these two stories start similar but go very different places by the end.

I really think the reason for the Hunger Games popularity comes from its ability to reach a broader audience. It has an almost scifi edge which helps tone the brutality, more focus on a specific protagonist, and being a trilogy hasn't hurt.

I agree that there is a similarity between Battle Royale and Hunger Games Book 1, but HG is a Trilogy, and the other two books bring something very different and unique to the table.

Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger.

About Me

My photo
The chaos isn't there for nothing! I'm Erika, the girl behind all the...disaster. You can definitely expect me to turn an ordinary, boring, same old situation into one big hell of a hot mess. Opinionated, a war freak and can totally pwn you in Dance Dance Revolution, I'm also pretty competitive so I always do my best in everything that I do. Keep reading my blog to see my view of things and how I dish out the awful truth on any topic.

Followers